First Page

Nvidia was not a black swan event

Most so-called black swans are known fragilities that nobody paid attention to. For sensible investors, defending against them is not difficult

Most so-called black swans are known fragilities that nobody paid attention to. For sensible investors, defending against them is not difficultAnand Kumar/AI-Generated Image

Summary: Within days of a scandal, Nvidia’s CEO was gone and social media had its label ready: black swan. It is a comforting word, because it means nobody could have seen it coming. Is that true? And what does the answer say about the bets sitting quietly in your own portfolio?

When the CEO of the world’s most important chip company resigned within days of a scandal breaking, with shares already down 13 per cent the previous week, a large crowd on social media reflexively reached for the phrase ‘black swan’ and paraded the episode as a perfect example. Nassim Taleb’s black swan is an event that lies outside any reasonable expectation, carries an extreme impact and is then explained away as obvious once it has happened. In my opinion, Jensen Huang’s exit from Nv.idia satisfies the second and third conditions, but I doubt that it satisfies the first.

Think of what was already in the public domain. American scrutiny of a large Singapore-based Nvidia customer, suspected of routing restricted chips towards China, began in 2024, and the press had been reporting on it since at least October 2025. The company was built around a co-founder who had led it since 1993, reportedly with 60 people reporting directly to him, and with no obvious successor. None of this predicts a resignation, but each item is a fragility that could have been written down long before anything went wrong. Most importantly, a share price carried to great heights by the AI boom assigned no cost at all to these fragilities.

The objection to what I say is also obvious. Hindsight makes everything look visible, and countless founder-led companies depend on one person without ever suffering a day of drama. Had I written this column a year ago, I could not have predicted this particular event, nor could anyone else. My argument does not need prediction. It only needs the fragility to be identifiable. Most investors never try to identify it when a stock is rising.

My team at Value Research put together a quick story last week for our readers on what the episode meant for Indian investors in US-focused funds. Nvidia fell 13 per cent in the week up to 11 November, yet most Indian funds investing in US shares lost only 1 to 3.2 per cent. Funds tracking the Nasdaq 100, where Nvidia carries a weight of about 8 per cent, lost roughly 1.1 to 1.3 per cent. The smaller the basket, the bigger the hit: funds tracking the ten-stock NYSE FANG+ index and the S&P 500 Top 50, where Nvidia is 10 to 12 per cent, lost 2.2 and 2.4 per cent. Nobody in those funds had forecast anything. Their investors were spared because no single company made up more than a modest part of the portfolio.

Limiting exposure is the only defence an ordinary investor has against a nasty surprise, since you cannot know which dependency will fail or when. What you can do is look for the dependencies themselves. Whenever you hold a business directly, ask what would break if one person, one customer, one licence or one government decision changed. Plenty of listed Indian companies, especially promoter-led ones, rest on the judgement and goodwill of a single individual, a single large client or a regulator. IRDAI’s recent paper on restructuring insurance distribution is a perfect example of the last kind: one regulatory decision could change the economics of every listed insurer and of the banks that sell their policies. Knowing such a dependency does not mean you must sell, but it does tell you how much exposure your portfolio should have.

A good test is to imagine any single holding losing half its value overnight and ask whether you could still meet your investment goals. If the answer is no, then your exposure is too large, no matter how good its past record. This works for the same reason the funds above limited the damage: it replaces an impossible forecast with an enforceable limit.

Calling an event a black swan is comfortable because it absolves everybody, including the analysts who praised the company and the investors who put too much of their savings in it. If nobody could have seen it coming, nobody needs to look, and nobody is to blame. Actually, the swan was white and was sitting right there. What was missing was someone willing to ask what it would cost if it flew off.

Also read: Nvidia tumbled. International funds took a far smaller hit

Ask Value Research aks value research information

No question is too small. Share your queries on personal finance, mutual funds, or stocks and let us simplify things for you.


Other Categories