Fund Advisor's Note

The automation trap

When everyone's investing automatically, who's doing the thinking?

When everyone's investing automatically, who's doing the thinking?Aditya Roy/AI-Generated Image

Everyone in the investment industry celebrates the massive success of the SIP revolution. That’s justified up to a point. SIPs represent one of the most sensible innovations in retail investing—a mechanism that removes the guesswork from market entry, harnesses the power of rupee cost averaging, and transforms investing from a sporadic burst of enthusiasm into a steady habit. The fact that crores of Indians automatically invest monthly is genuinely good news for the country's financial future. I’ve spent practically an entire lifetime being an unpaid cheerleader for SIPs, but now find some aspects of the revolution disquieting. Somewhere along the way, SIPs have transformed from a useful tool into an almost mystical solution to all investment woes. The very success of the SIP concept has bred a dangerous complacency that threatens to undermine its effectiveness. The problem isn't with SIPs themselves--it's with how they're being sold and understood. The marketing machinery has essentially rebranded SIPs as "Fill It, Shut it, Forget it" solut

This article was originally published on July 21, 2025.

Fund Advisor

Buy, hold, or switch. Get the call.

How's my portfolio doing? What do I need to fix? Where should I invest next? Fund Advisor answers each one. The Advisor Note every Saturday. A live session with Dhirendra Kumar every second Saturday.

No commissions. No conflicts. Since 1991.

See Plans right-arrow

Other Categories