The Plan

On a Sound Footing

Temper some of your financial goals and you should sail through

I am 43 years old. We are a family of four with two dependants- my son and my mother. What do I need to do to my portfolio to achieve my financial goals
- Chandrashekhara

Earnings and Expenditure
Our observation
Rs 44,000 goes towards your loan payments and investments. If we add your expenses, it comes up to Rs 49,000. Where does the balance amount go? Moreover, are you sure your monthly household expenses amount to just Rs 5,000?

Inflows and Outflows
Monthly Income  
Husband 60,000
Wife 12,000
Monthly Outgo  
EMI towards house and land loan 20,000
EMI towards car loan 3,000
Household expenses 5,000
Investments  
Provident Fund Contribution 10,000
Mutual fund SIPs 11,000
All figures in Rs

Other Investments
I have an accumulation of Rs 2.5 lakh in my provident fund account and a fixed deposit of Rs 2.5 lakh.

Our observation
You have not mentioned how much money you have in a savings account. If you need money for an emergency, is this a flexi deposit which you can break with ease?

Our suggestion
Keep around a few months' salary for this and distribute it between a savings account and maybe a liquid fund. In the case of the latter, you will only get the money after one working day.

Insurance
My employer has provided me with a health insurance of Rs 6 lakh, which also covers the family members.

Our observation
What about life insurance covers for you and your wife since you both are earning members? You obviously have no personal medical cover of your own. What if you resign from this job or take a sabbatical, what cover does your family have? Even if you take a new job, there will be an interim period between jobs when you are not covered.

Our suggestion
Take a life insurance cover, preferably term insurance, for you and your wife. Also take out your personal mediclaim policy.

Mutual Fund Investments
I began investing via systematic investment plans (SIPs) only last year in the funds mentioned. The current value of my mutual fund portfolio is Rs 1.60 lakh.

Our observation

  • You have not gone overboard with your fund selection and have narrowed down on good picks. You also refrained from investing at one go and have done so via SIPs. This is good.
  • You have way too much exposure to mid-cap funds. You must have been lured by the performance of such funds last year. We are not saying you should avoid such funds, but limit the overall exposure. These funds do yield a higher return than large caps but they also have a high degree of downside risk associated with them.
  • The large number of mid cap funds in your portfolio has resulted in numerous stocks with most having an insignificant allocation; 278 stocks out of which 253 have an allocation of less than 1 per cent.
  • Why have you picked up a monthly income plan (MIP)? It's not that you need the regular income.
  • Why have you duplicated fund houses, pick different schemes from different asset management companies.

My Monthly SIPs  (Rs)
HDFC TOP 200 2,000
HDFC Equity 2,000
Principal Emerging Bluechip 1,000
ICICI Prudential Discovery 1,000
DSP BR Micro Cap 1,000
DSP BR Small & Mid Cap 1,000
Reliance MIP 3,000

Action points on SIPs

  • Make your portfolio predominantly large-cap tilted. Currently you have around half of your portfolio allocated to large caps, bring it up to 70 per cent.
  • The two mid-cap funds in which you can continue with your SIP are ICICI Prudential Discovery and DSP BR Small & Mid Cap.
  • Continue with HDFC TOP 200 (Large & Mid Cap) and HDFC Equity (Multi Cap).
  • Discontinue your SIP in DSP BR Micro Cap and Principal Emerging Bluechip. Start SIPs in large-cap funds - IDFC Imperial Equity and Franklin India Bluechip.
  • Currently you have around 17 per cent in debt, which is good. The equity exposure of Reliance MIP can vary between 0 and 20 per cent, depending on the fund manager's view. So, your equity and debt allocation will fluctuate accordingly. Instead, discontinue your SIP in Reliance MIP and start one in a pure debt long-term debt fund like Birla Sun Life Dynamic bond or Canara Robeco Income.
  • Increase your SIPs to Rs 16,000/month.

Suggested Portfolio
Scheme  Monthly SIP (Rs)  Category
HDFC Equity 3,000 Multi Cap
IDFC Imperial Equity 3,000 Large Cap
Franklin India Bluechip 3,000 Large Cap
HDFC TOP 200 2,000 Large & Mid Cap
ICICI Prudential Discovery 1,000 Mid & Small Cap
DSP BR Small & Mid Cap 1,000 Mid & Small Cap
Birla Sun Life Dynamic Bond 3,000 Debt Income

Goals
With my current SIPs, will I be able to achieve my financial goals? I can increase the SIPs by Rs 5,000. Please suggest.

Our observation

  • You started off with your investments very late. Considering that you will be retiring in 15 years, it won't be possible to do so.
  • You are currently investing Rs 11,000 a month in mutual funds and you can increase it by another Rs 5,000. To achieve your current goals you need to make an investment of around Rs 1.40 lakh per month. We have arrived at this figure by taking an annual inflation rate of 6.5 per cent and a return on your investments of 15 per cent per annum. We have also assumed that you won't be investing after your retirement.
  • One goal which you can knock off is buying a second house, since you already have one. Instead, we think you should focus on your retirement kitty.
    • Financial Goals
        Year  Value at current prices  Inflation adjusted value
      Second house 2015 61 87
      Son's education 2023 25 64
      Retirement corpus 2025 120 355
      Son's marriage 2034 10 56
      Figures in Rs/lakh


      This article was originally published on December 02, 2010.

Ask Value Research aks value research information

No question is too small. Share your queries on personal finance, mutual funds, or stocks and let us simplify things for you.


Other Categories

Mutual Fund Insight turns 24! 🎉 Get 2 FREE anniversary guides: The Right SIP + The Big Funds