Here is the concluding part of the discussion I had with an ex-student who wanted to understand his future by posing these questions to me:
Sir, I didn't understand “When improvements in productivity from a technological innovation are evenly (and quickly) distributed across the economy, there is no “differential” effect on GDP, and nobody captures any “value”.” If everyone's productivity goes up then shouldn't the number of transactions and hence the velocity of money go up and affect the GDP correspondingly?
The cost of solar based transportation infrastructure is humungous by any standard. The whole concept of grid parity comes up because oil is at US$100. At US$30 solar starts hitting theoretical efficiency limits and there is no parity. Not with present technology anyway--it needs something completely new in all probability...and that new thing is not Moore's law compliant.
GDP only goes up in 2 ways: either you increase the number of people, or you increase (factor) productivity. The latter refers to differential productivity. When everybody was on calculators, you had a certain factor productivity to the production of steel because you needed that many clerks/ secretaries to run a steel company (30,000 people for about 2 million tonne capacity in Russi Mody's Tata Steel). Today, with laptops, you don't need secretaries and comptists, so you make 11 million tonne steel with say, 70,000 people. Get the point?
If everybody is doing the same, real costs of steel production will drop, as we can see in many areas (computers, telecom, manufacturing, now even energy). Yes, a drop in the real cost of anything brings in new demand (as can be seen spectacularly in telecom), so GDP increases...that was precisely my point, when I said that when energy costs disappear from the GDP of nations, you will see an explosion in activity, such that nobody will notice that energy is now free.
Can you imagine what would happen if the cost of food was controlled by 16 “food companies”, the way energy is so controlled. The fact that wheat prices are determined by a genuine perfect market, is one of the reasons why we are still alive. Imagine if energy and drugs and pharma was available in the same (perfectly competitive) manner. All the ingredients of life: water, food, energy and pharma should be so available, don't you think? That would equalise the world in a manner that no economic policy would. The sun sends down to earth energy that is some crazy times the requirement of humans. 0.3 per cent of the Sahara desert can meet the entire energy needs of Europe, at current levels of technology; similarly, some 3 per cent of the Thar desert can do the same for India. Increase in energy demand, yes, and that is what will get the world out of this hole. Demand on land, forget it...if the cost of energy goes down to zero, they will reclaim land from the sea!!! Or they will put up Solar panels over the sea. About limits on conversion efficiency, that is the same point as the limit on land.
Solar energy can be used to 'recycle' Co2 back into oil, which will get past the infrastructural requirements of transmitting solar energy into transportation. The big game changer will be grid parity, that is all. Any drop (in the capital cost of Solar PV) below that and some tectonic changes will start. The first will be the demise of coal, then gas...and then, energy demand will start to explode on the back of an explosion in economic activity.
Before you retire, these trends will be well on the way. In fact, my bet is that the trend may be over and you will retire in a post-industrial world...
I guess we both agree on the fact that it is going to happen--5 years here or there. In 30 years the world will definitely not be like this. Other than energy, what other fundamental shifts do you see in our lifetimes?
In bio-sciences, we will start to regenerate tissue, even complete organs. In environment sciences, we will see an explosion in our understanding of the inter-linkages of the environment. In medicine, we will have targeted medicines, nano-medicine and the end of invasive surgery as we know it.
In manufacturing, we will be recycling everything, virgin materials will be finished and the mining industry will end. 3-D printing will allow us to customise production to unique requirements. Agriculture as we know it will be finished; we will have micro-irrigation, bio-engineered pesticides and genetically modified seeds in the food chain.
We will end poverty as we know it, in the emerging countries. The only challenge will be to find jobs...and as I write it, I think it will be faster rather than later.
One would be free to choose (the work) one wants and not need payment for it. How do you think these changes affect the monetary and financial world? Considering that the entire field of economics and its derivatives is founded on the principle of scarcity, this could be a very fundamental change to how the society is structured and functions.
I don't think poverty means the same thing to the both of us. To me poverty refers to the inability to find life's necessities: food, water, energy, waste disposal (garbage, sewerage and toilets), housing. To you, it seems to mean “all material want”.
Most of our real aspirations start after we get past poverty. We will still want jobs, we will still want work, long after the highest bar that defines poverty is well behind us...
Only the first two of the aspirations in Maslow's hierarchy have to do with material want; the other three are all about “finding happiness”, which by the way, is one of the new definitions of economics: the maximising of happiness.
And if you define happiness, it is “complex ever-evolving work, some good relationships (including with the opposite sex), charity and hope for a better future. When you have everything, you still want to hope for a better future.
By the end of poverty, I was referring to a situation where the real cost of life's necessities drops to near zero, not difficult to imagine. It has reached such a situation in Denmark, Sweden, Norway, Luxembourg, Austria and a few other OECD countries. Do you see them stopping to work? Economics is not only about scarce resources, it now has a new definition, the maximising of happiness.
On economics being about maximising happiness, the problem that has not been solved is that there is no reliable or accepted way of measuring happiness. Another problem in my opinion with that view is that nobody cares about maximising happiness of any society--I have never heard of any instance, real or fictional, where people have ever tried to compete for this. Also, it is very subjective--people have been known to be very happy in abject poverty too. Another problem with maximising happiness--it is designed as a reward mechanism not as a steady state. Long point in short.., unless it can be understood well enough to be measured and manipulated...it is like philosophy...it is fun to indulge in.
Read my previous comments again...if two per cent of the population starts to produce 100 per cent of the basic needs of the entire population, then the rest of the population does not need to 'work'. Now what does it do? There has to be some transmission mechanism by which money moves back from the producers into the hands of the consumers (of the necessities); in the US, two per cent of the population produces all the food, but the rest are busy making software, or movies! So the real cost of food has dropped, and that is good because unemployment is still seven per cent; but what if unemployment goes to 35 per cent, and most of the population is poor in a very rich country?
The challenge is of meaningful jobs; you can't be happy living on food stamps. But if productivity reaches the levels I imagine, then yes, we will have to have an ever more complex, 'tertiary' economy that is busy thinking, innovating, researching (there are 7 million scientists today, as many as there ever were...)
About maximising happiness, remember that the original name of Economics was 'Moral Philosophy'. Having diffused objectives is not a problem for a subject that started as art, went on to become a 'science', got mathematical and remains in the realm of commerce....
A similar stated goal is also found in Nanotechnology where self healing and self assembling machines are the holy grail: Machines building machines. To generalise-- humans, though they started with basic tools to replace the work that can be done by their hands, have given increasingly complex tasks to machines. Humans then found work in building more complex tools, or monitoring machines or increasing their productivity. And soon enough they will build machines to do that too--the efforts are on. But the size of the globe/population/ resources imposes certain constraints on how much productivity increases can be done. I am sure that human learning capability and production costs also impose a constraint on the speed of innovation.
Also, for the first time in human history we are hitting global limits on resources and expansion opportunities. The framework which promotes viral growth is slowly turning from asset to liability. Maybe the model that measures growth (GDP or any other) would in future be replaced by balance or sustainability based models.