First Page • Mutual Fund Insight - Dec 2026

Made for each other, revisited

Small-cap funds have had a muted return in recent years. Yet, the case for continuing small-cap SIPs remains strong.

Small-cap funds have had a muted return in recent years. Yet, the case for continuing small-cap SIPs remains strong.Anand Kumar/AI-Generated Image

Summary: This column explains where the small-cap SIP advantage did and didn’t show up, and why the case for continuing SIPs rests on keeping you invested, not on higher returns. It ends by pointing to allocation, fund choice and holding period as the decisions that matter more.

In July 2016, I wrote on this page that regular SIP investments in a small-cap fund exploit volatility and enhance returns, and made a comparison that I thought settled the matter. At the time, over the five years to June 2016, Franklin India Small Cap Fund gave 24.6 per cent a year to a lumpsum investor and 32 per cent through an SIP, a gain of 7.4 percentage points, against 3.9 points for SBI Large Cap Fund.

Two years later, in an editorial titled ‘Made for Each Other’, I went further and called SIPs and small-cap funds a match made in heaven. I believed it then, but the data behind this month’s cover story doesn’t support it the way I expected. That said, it teaches us something valuable about small-cap investing and SIPs.

Over 10 years, a lumpsum in the median small-cap fund gave 15.2 per cent a year, ahead of mid caps at 14.3 per cent. The median 10-year SIP in small caps has earned 15.7 per cent, so the SIP has added just half a percentage point. Over shorter periods, the picture turns.

Someone who began a monthly SIP in a small-cap fund three years ago earned a median 4.5 per cent a year, while a lumpsum invested on the first day gave 12.5 per cent. The same is true in every category we checked: over three and five years, the SIP trailed the lumpsum. In 2016, I would have predicted the largest benefit in small caps. The data now suggest the benefit is modest and can’t be relied on in any category.

Much of the explanation lies in how an SIP works. Because it buys at every price along the way, it looks brilliant when the market dips after you begin and looks ordinary in the opposite case. The five years I chose in 2016 happened to contain the kind of dip that rewards regular buying. The last three years did the opposite. The investor of 2023 bought most instalments at prices already pushed up by investors who were there before. With assets in small-cap funds up 77 per cent since February 2024, Rs 1.4 lakh crore of it fresh money, anyone starting today is again buying alongside a large crowd. I am therefore withdrawing the claim that an SIP in a small-cap fund can be counted on to raise returns.

What I am keeping is the advice to continue SIPs, because the case for it rests on behaviour. An automatic instalment keeps a person invested through the stretches when small caps become very hard to hold. In March 2025, with small caps down about 25 per cent, I argued against veterans telling investors to stop their SIPs and run, and that argument hasn’t changed. Stopping in a fall means skipping the instalments that buy at the lowest prices, and running turns a paper loss into a real one. The cover story shows how much staying matters. Of all the monthly SIPs in the Nifty Smallcap 250 since 2006, nearly one in four lost money over three years; over 10 years, only one in 130 did. The volatility I called a friend in 2016 and a contract in 2025 remains the price of returns, and an SIP is a sensible way to pay it.

If the SIP cannot be relied upon to enhance returns, the decisions around it carry more weight than I used to give them: how much of your money goes into small caps, which fund you choose and how long you stay. The cover story finds that over five years, the gap between a small-cap fund in the top quarter and one in the bottom is 5.2 percentage points a year, against 2 for large-cap funds. It suggests keeping mid- and small-cap funds together at no more than 25-30 per cent of your portfolio, counting the small companies hidden inside funds outside the category. It discusses five small-cap funds that pass its tests, and five funds from other categories that hold a sizable share in small caps. I would read it as a guide to the SIP as the habit that keeps you invested, and to decisions about allocation, fund choice and holding period as the ones that will determine your returns.

Ask Value Research aks value research information

No question is too small. Share your queries on personal finance, mutual funds, or stocks and let us simplify things for you.


4 million + Issues sold
magazine-image
physical copy option Physical Copy
pdf reader option PDF Reader
web copy option Web Copy
mobile app option Mobile App

Top Picks

HDFC vs ICICI AMC: Same business, different balance sheets

5 min read•By  Lakshya Naredi

Welcome to the New Value Research!

2 min read•By  Value Research

Would you pay ₹30 to earn ₹1? Three checks before you pay up

5 min read•By  Mohammed Ekramul Haque

Mahanadi IPO: Coal India's best mine, priced for no growth

5 min read•By  Lakshya Naredi

Hundreds of schemes, a handful of indices

1 min read•By  Aakar Rastogi