What are cyclical and defensive stocks?

In Soviet Russia, chess was a religion. Such that it has produced some enduring names of the sport – Kasparov and Karpov, to name a few. The region had a characteristic style of play – the Soviet school of chess – that was popularised by the great Mikhail Botvinnik.

He reigned supreme for over 30 years. However, in 1960, 23-year-old Mikhail Tal defeated him in a series of thrilling games which featured his notable sacrificial play.

While conservatism would have favoured Botvinnik most of the time, the world sometimes throws a curveball at you. This unpredictability is even truer in the world of investing.

During a bull run, most investors invest in sectors that are performing; thus, they pick up cyclical stocks randomly. However, you need defensive stocks that your portfolio can benefit from during market slumps. We’ll show you how to balance them in your portfolio.

What are cyclical stocks?

Cyclical stocks rise through economic booms and just as quickly fall during busts. Their revenues and profits rise and fall in tune with the broader economy. When the economy expands, consumers and businesses spend more, lifting the fortunes of these companies.

Conversely, during economic slowdowns or recessions, these companies tend to feel the pinch first, often experiencing sharper declines.

Some typical sectors and industries that fall under cyclical stocks include:

• Automobiles
• Real estate and construction
• Travel, tourism, and aviation
• Metals and commodities

These industries rely heavily on discretionary spending and capital investments thus their performance is intricately tied to economic trends.

Suggested read: Mutual funds, Autopilots and Air Crashes

What are the characteristics of cyclical stocks?

Understanding cyclical stocks’ behaviour can help investors avoid common pitfalls. Here are key characteristics:

• Highly sensitive to consumer and business spending: Their earnings often fluctuate widely with changes in demand.
• Strong earnings growth during economic booms: When times are good, cyclical stocks can outperform other stocks significantly.
• Sharp declines during recessions: These companies tend to suffer steep drops in earnings and stock prices during downturns.
• Higher volatility: Price swings can be more pronounced compared to the broader market.
• Price traps for momentum chasers: Cyclical stocks may appear cheap at the top of a cycle and expensive at the bottom, luring investors into bad timing decisions. Using a valuation metric like P/E will also prove futile, as earnings per share is part of the calculation. Therefore, when the market is high, the P/E will be low, thus luring new investors who are on the lookout for bargains.

Suggested read: Should you invest in cyclical stocks?

What are defensive stocks?

On the flip side, defensive stocks offer stability amid uncertainty. These companies provide essential or non-discretionary products and services, such as food, healthcare, utilities, and telecommunications. Consumers tend to buy these regardless of the economy’s health, ensuring relatively stable revenue and earnings streams.

Common examples include:

• Pharmaceuticals
• Fast-moving consumer goods (FMCG)
• Utilities like electricity and water
• Healthcare services

These stocks tend to be less sensitive to economic fluctuations, making them a safe harbour during turbulent times.

Suggested read: Stick to your lane

What are the characteristics of defensive stocks?

Here are the traits that set defensive stocks apart:

• Less sensitivity to economic cycles: Revenue and earnings remain stable even during recessions.
• Regular dividends: Many defensive stocks pay regular dividends, providing a steady income.
• Lower volatility: These stocks generally move less dramatically than cyclical stocks.
• Stable or rising valuations during market downturns: Defensive stocks often retain or increase value when markets correct.

Suggested read: The power of questions

Cyclical vs Defensive stocks: The key differences

Knowing these differences can help you align your portfolio with your risk tolerance and market outlook.

What is the best investment strategy based on the market cycle?

While an understanding of economic cycles is crucial to investing in stocks, timing them is like catching lightning in a bottle. Navigating these cycles can be challenging for reasons rooted in psychology.

First, you need in-depth knowledge of each sector to know how different businesses will deal with the headwind. Furthermore, if you do spot a business that looks good on paper, you still need to identify the reasons that it’ll survive the bad phase.

Second, it is almost impossible to know when a sector will bottom out. As a result, if you do invest in a business with hopes of making out of the down-cycle alive, it’ll take many years before you notice any improvement. After all, each phase of a cycle lasts a long time.

You’d need a stomach of steel to withstand the stress of it all. 

And the worst-case scenario? It is a value trap that you mistook for a gem, and you just wasted your time and effort.

Lastly, very few investors are good at admitting their mistakes. So when they face a situation where an investment doesn’t make them money, they hold onto it. While staying invested is a good strategy, you also need to know how to cut your losses.

Due to the sunk cost fallacy, most don’t walk out of their losers. Instead, they should have invested in something more lucrative much earlier. Hence, they suffer a huge opportunity cost.

Therefore, choose quality businesses that you understand the economics of. This means you should know the channels that generate revenue and the key drivers of profit for the business. Thorough research is the only way to find businesses that can generate sustained growth for you.

Suggested read: Kahneman’s final lesson

What common mistakes should investors avoid?

Investing in cyclical and defensive stocks comes with its own set of traps. Avoid these pitfalls:

• Chasing cyclical stocks at cycle tops: Buying cyclical stocks when they already look “cheap” at the top often leads to losses.
• Ignoring defensive stocks due to low growth: Defensive stocks may seem dull but are crucial for portfolio stability.
• Assuming past cycles repeat exactly, Economic cycles evolve; past performance doesn’t guarantee future results.
• Neglecting fundamentals: Avoid buying or holding stocks purely based on momentum without assessing the underlying business.

Staying disciplined and sticking to a research-backed strategy will serve investors well.

Suggested read: Avoid the doughnut of incompetence

Conclusion

When the world throws a curveball at you, you have to be prepared. Taking reckless bets on rising sectors ensures you lose wealth. At the same time, being too conservative is also hazardous for your wealth.

You need to have a balance between risk and return. And your mix of cyclical and defensive stocks will reflect that. By matching your financial needs and risk profile, you can build a portfolio that grows and protects your hard-earned money.

However, if you find that the research needed to succeed is too demanding, you can try out Value Research Stock Advisor. We offer monthly recommendations along with buy, sell, and hold calls to help you find the best opportunities in an ever-changing market.

FAQs

1. What sectors are considered cyclical stocks?

Cyclical stocks commonly include automobiles, real estate, consumer durables, metals, travel, and tourism—industries that thrive in economic expansions.

2. Why are defensive stocks important during market downturns?

Defensive stocks provide stable earnings and dividends, helping protect portfolios from steep losses during recessions.

3. Can I rely solely on cyclical stocks for long-term growth?

While cyclical stocks offer growth during expansions, they can suffer severe declines in downturns. A balanced portfolio with defensive stocks is advisable for risk management.

4. How do I decide my allocation between cyclical and defensive stocks?

It depends on your risk tolerance, investment goals, and market outlook.

5. Are there mutual funds that focus specifically on cyclical or defensive sectors?

Yes, many mutual funds target sector-specific investments, including funds focused on cyclical sectors like infrastructure or defensive sectors like FMCG.

Also read: The art of elimination

This article was originally published on May 30, 2025.