
While watching the series scam of 1992, I'm wearily reminded of the time of the stock market bubble which seems apparent today as well, with mind-boggling valuations on stocks without any fundamental improvement. Do you still suggest for retail investors to invest right now? If so, why and how?
- Aliasgar Khambati
1992 and 2020 are very different. In 1992, Harshad Mehta took the bank's money and invested in the market. This was unusual and unprecedented. The Indian markets were the old generation. Everything was done on the trading floor that you are watching in the series now. So, the market complexion has changed, the number of investors has increased now as FIIs were not allowed to invest earlier.
One more important thing is that SEBI did not exist in 1992. In fact, SEBI came into being because of the 1992 scam. So, we have a stock market regulator as a result of the 1992 scam. We have a diverse set of investors, domestic institutions such as mutual funds, which we did not have at the time. As you find in that series, the only thing that was being referred to was UTI and that was it.
Today, we have many mutual funds and they are channelising money into the markets. We have bigger AMCs than UTI in the mutual fund business. So, I don't see a concentration of investors and if a lot of investors pull out money in a hurry in a brief period of time, the markets can collapse. We witnessed it in 2008 when the markets went down by about 45 per cent. We saw it in March this year when the pandemic hit and the result was that the markets went down by about 40 per cent in just a few sessions. That was quite unreal and it can happen if a lot of investors come and take their money out.
But I don't see that the market can go down and remain there for a long period of time, which we witnessed in 1992. In 1992, the scam was unearthed and the money went out. Many years after the event, we achieved the 4000 level on the Sensex. So, I would say that in 1992, the complexion of the market was very skewed towards a few people, it could be manipulated and the 1992 scam was a complete manipulation. In 2020, we are far more diverse investors who are making informed decisions. So with the varied investor set, I don't see a racket of that kind.
With regard to any valuation concerns, if you have witnessed, banking stocks have not generated any return in about three-four years now. I think we find pockets of undervaluation, we find a set of industries where investors haven't made any money. In fact, they have lost money and only for a small segment of the market where investors have made money, their valuations have gone up. For instance, if you look at the complexion of the banking sector, only three companies actually make all the money and the rest of the industry loses money. So, we find that money is getting concentrated in fewer companies and they are very high-quality companies.
There could be a case of time correction wherein the market doesn't go up so your money is not growing and time passes by. That is the worst scenario which I've witnessed. To deal with this, I would say that stick to a plan. You should always reduce the possibility of catching a market high. That is what is it in the hands of an individual investor because if you get worried about the valuation or 50 other concerns, and I'll mostly agree with them, but then you have to be in the market because the biggest turnaround happens when you least expect it.





