First Page

PSU ETF Opens, but is No Longer a Good Investment

On listing, the CPSE ETF no longer looks like the good investment it did during the NFO

CPSE(Central Public Sector Enterprises) ETF has listed on the stock markets today. The This Exchange Traded Fund is a specialised fund that Goldman Sachs Mutual Fund has launched to help the government sell public sector stocks. The CPSE index opened at Rs 1,944 today, which is a gain of 7 per cent on it's price on the day that the issue closed. Each unit of the CPSE ETF is 1/10th the price of the index. However, during the interim period, it has hit a high of 1991.95 on 2nd April and is now looking decidedly anaemic.

The New Fund Offer (NFO) of the fund had been quite successful. As Goldman's advertisements in today's newspapers point out, Rs 4,363.39 crores was collected from 38,409 applications. That's a pretty good response from what is never a particularly well-favoured part of the market. As our earlier article pointed out, what made this issue attractive were two special features. One, a five per cent discount, and two, a 1:15 bonus one year down the line.

The advertising in the newspaper tells investors that if they couldn't subscribe to the NFO, they should go and buy the ETF on the markets through their brokers when it lists today to get a slice of these 'PSU Crown Jewels'. However, now that the ETF has actually listed, it doesn't look like such an attractive bet. Both the reasons were available only for those who invested during the NFO alone. So, not only the price has run up quite a bit, the two sweeteners are also no longer available.

Now, all that investors have are the regular disadvantages of buying into stocks which have the uncertainty of having the government as promoter. As we had pointed out at the time of the NFO, it's generally not a good idea for fund investors to invest in sectoral or a thematic fund. The whole point of investing through an equity fund is that you should not have to decide whether and how much exposure you should have to a certain type of stock and how long you should maintain that exposure. That's why it makes sense for fund investors to invest only in diversified funds.

However, even if one accepts the logic of a particular theme, it has to be an investing-related theme, like banks or IT or consumer goods or auto or something else that looks like doing better than the rest of the market. The CPSE ETF is not like that. Instead, it's a thematic fund where the theme happens to be the promoter. And not a promoter who is known for looking after the interest of the business or the minority shareholders.



Ask Value Research aks value research information

No question is too small. Share your queries on personal finance, mutual funds, or stocks and let us simplify things for you.


Other Categories