Can this small-cap stock deliver on its bold promise of 50x revenue growth?

Every so often, the market throws up stories that spark both excitement and scepticism in equal measure. Kiri Industries is the latest to do so. Known for its dyes business, the small-cap company is turning heads with its audacious plan to increase its revenue by a gigantic 50 times in the next three to four years! This means a revenue of Rs 50,000 crore, up from Rs 949 crore in FY24.

How does it plan to achieve this unprecedented growth in such a short span? That the company got its hands on a magic pill is more believable than its actual gameplan. We provide a reality check for its ambitious target:

From dyes to copper: Kiri Industries' giant leap

The company plans to venture into copper refining to achieve its revenue goal. Its confidence stems from an expected Rs 4,000-5,000 crore windfall from its stake in an associate company, DyStar, following a protracted legal battle.

Transitioning from dyes to copper refining is no small pivot. Kiri Industries aims to invest Rs 8,000 crore in two phases to set up a facility with a 5 lakh tonne annual capacity encompassing a mix of smelting, refining, and recycling processes to produce copper products and associated byproducts. This is a bold move for a company with no prior experience in the sector.

Even the big guns are taking it easy

For comparison, Hindalco, one of India's leading copper refiners, is spending the same Rs 8,000 crore to expand its smelting capacity by 3 lakh tonnes. If a giant like Hindalco could only achieve up to 3 lakh tonnes of capacity with a similar capex, it would require a smaller player like Kiri Industries excessive control on efficiency to achieve a higher capacity of 5 lakh tonnes.

Next, Kiri Industries's guidance of Rs 50,000 crore revenue from its planned capacity is astronomical when it takes Hindalco double the capacity (10 lakh tonnes) to generate roughly the same amount. Kiri's EBITDA margin projection of 10-12 per cent also far exceeds Hindalco's 5-7 per cent margin. This raises the question whether Kiri Industries is banking on unrealistically high copper prices or an overly favourable demand-supply equation to justify its revenue goal?

Suggested read: Fine-tuning the future

The company is confident that India's gaping demand-supply gap in the copper market will assist new players find their footing. India is a net importer of copper, heavily relying on overseas supplies to meet local demand. The country consumes nearly 15 lakh tonnes of copper annually but produces only 4 lakh tonnes, leaving a significant portion to be met through imports.

The gap is only set to rise with copper consumption expected to rise to nearly 30 lakh tonnes by 2030, driven by renewable energy projects, electric vehicles, and urbanisation. While this is a critical tailwind for the sector, it's important to note that Hindalco, with its established expertise and infrastructure, is taking a measured expansion approach. It has many reasons to do so. The most important being the capital-intensive, operationally complex nature of copper refining.

The industry requires significant infrastructure and skilled manpower to maintain consistent output quality. There are ample challenges like fluctuating commodity prices, high energy costs, and stringent environmental regulations. These factors collectively raise the stakes for new entrants. Kiri Industries's aggressive expansion plans warrant scrutiny, especially when established players are proceeding cautiously.

Suggested read: Should you invest in cyclical stocks?

Does its books hold enough strength?

Can Kiri Industries' balance sheet support an Rs 8,000 crore capex? The company has indicated that roughly two-thirds of the Rs 8,000 crore capex will be funded via debt. This is because the company's cash flow from its existing business is insufficient, raising concerns about its financial leverage and repayment capability.

Moreover, a closer examination of the company's profitability reveals a critical detail—a significant portion of its profit after tax comes from the share of profits from associates and joint ventures. This is largely an accounting treatment, not actual cash flows. Over the past five years, the company reported more than Rs 200 crore every year as profit from associates, while its operating profit remained highly volatile, reflecting challenges in core operations.

A case for prudence

The company's grand guidance suggests it's either underestimating its costs or wildly overestimating its potential. The fact that it scaled back the proposed capacity of the copper facility to 5 lakh tonne from 10 lakh tonne suggests a strategy that is still evolving, or challenges in accurately assessing project feasibility.

Value investors may be drawn to invest to reap potential gains (through dividends etc) from the one-time windfall arising from DyStar's stake sale. However, the company's decision to channel these funds into copper refining demands revisiting that decision. Considering the risks of venturing into an unfamiliar and demanding industry like copper refining, the odds for the company are likely not in favour.

Before you leave

Let us introduce you to a revolutionary strategy called 'Dividend Growth Investing'. This approach focuses on companies with a consistent track record of growing their dividends, offering both steady income and long-term growth potential.

Our exclusive Dividend Growth Portfolio from Value Research Stock Advisor is built around this strategy - featuring 10 high-quality stocks designed to help you grow and preserve your wealth.

Subscribe to Value Research Stock Advisor and explore the Dividend Growth Portfolio today!

Also read: Bharat Global Developers: Inside the 3,000 per cent stock rally that fooled everyone