Marketwire

Portfolio P/E need not be linked to NAV of a fund

Portfolio P/E may or may not directly linked to the net asset value of a fund the way stock price is linked to P/E

Market valuations are calculated in terms of multiples of price to earnings (P-E) ratio, which basically indicates the price you are willing to pay for one unit of earnings. But while the P-E of one stock measures how much the market is willing to pay for a constant growth represented by the historical earnings or for the future growth represented by estimated forward earnings, the P-E of a portfolio can't be interpreted in the same manner. Portfolio P-E may or may not be directly linked to net asset value of a fund the way stock price is linked to P-E.

HIGH Versus Low portfolio P-E
When you look at a particular stock, the trailing P-E ratio will show what the market is willing to pay for current earnings of a company. This can be compared with the forward P-E, which is essentially current price divided by the estimated future annual earnings. If the future earnings are expected to grow at a rate faster than the previous few years, then the forward P-E is likely to be lower than the trailing P-E (given that price considered is the same), and vice versa. This can be compared with the trailing and forward P-Es of a competitor with similar attributes. Ideally, a stock with lower P-E and higher growth should be favoured. But for a portfolio, the P-E ratio is the weighted average P-E for each stock in the portfolio. A portfolio can have stocks with both high and low P-E ratios, however it may not be accurate to compare these as they could belong to different sectors. For example, in case of cyclical sectors such as metals, mining and cement, P-E ratios are usually low.

For high-growth sectors that are technology or research driven, such as information technology (IT) and pharmaceuticals, P-E ratios are consistently higher. Hence, the stock selection and the weights assigned will ultimately determine the weighted average P-E. This holds true for an index or for an actively managed fund. Hence, comparing P-E ratios of two funds or indices may not be valid, even if the base characteristics are similar. Say, for two large-cap oriented funds, one might come up with a P-E of 16 times and another 13 times, whereas the S&P BSE Sensex has a P-E of 19 times. Does it mean both the funds are better valued and more likely to outperform? It's hard to decide as the data doesn't reveal much about stock selection. If the portfolios have a large number of stocks with low P-E but also low earnings growth, then outperformance against the index is unlikely. Similarly, a portfolio with high P-E stocks from growth sectors may do better than a portfolio that has more weight in cyclical stocks, say, at a time when the industrial cycle is on a downturn.

Portfolio or fund strategy matters
A value-oriented fund is likely to have a low P-E, compared with a fund run with a growth strategy. Hence, comparing P-E ratios of two portfolios may not work. Also, the P-E of a large-cap strategy can't be compared with the P-E of a mid- or small-cap fund. The portfolio P-E is useful to compare current position versus historical range. For example, for the S&P BSE Sensex, the 10-year average P-E (trailing) is around 18.5 times and the current is at 19.4 times, which is above average. But keep in mind that portfolio composition changes over time, leading to change in P-E range.

In arrangement with HT Syndication | MINT

Ask Value Research aks value research information

No question is too small. Share your queries on personal finance, mutual funds, or stocks and let us simplify things for you.


Other Categories

Informed fund ideas, better judgment. Every month. Mutual Fund Insight, every month since October 2002.

Take charge. Know more. Keep more. Mutual Fund Insight helps you do all three — every month