VR Logo

Profiting From The Great Panic

Don’t let today’s market crash bother you; use the volatility to your advantage by investing now…

Many times in the past years, publications from Value Research have published articles in response to investors’ need to response to a particular market situation. In every one of these articles, regardless of whether the markets have looked good, bad or ugly, we’ve given exactly the same advice. Not only that, the whole point of our advice is that it has always been the same.

The Value Research Way
Now is possibly the most stressful situation that Indian equity investors have ever faced. Let’s take a look at what we’ve said in the past, and how the Great Panic of 2008 reinforces the principles behind our advice. Here’s a summary of those unchanging principles.

Any investor who has followed this advice is sitting pretty today, largely unaffected by the Great Panic. The market value of your investments may be down today, but since you don’t need any of it for many years to come, that doesn’t matter. Long before you’ll need the money, it would have had a chance to start growing again.

Today, the natural response of many investors to what we’re saying is that right now, they’ve lost money. They say, “The returns may come back in the future, but what about the losses that I’ve made today". Those who say this are right in their arithmetic, but completely wrong in their assumptions. The only way to avoid the occasional crash is to be able to see the future, and if you could see into the future then you wouldn’t be reading this magazine any way. The whole point of investment approach that we are advocating is that it eliminates the need to see into the future.

The Past Proves the Point
The actual track record of the past decade shows that this approach works quite well. If you had started investing Rs 20,000 a month in a Sensex-based index fund in early 1997 and had continued to do so without regard to the ups and downs of the market, then today your rate of return would have stood at 14 per cent per annum. In all, you would have gradually put in Rs 28.6 lakh and these investments would have stood at Rs 66 lakh today, after the crash.
During this period, many mutual funds have comfortably beaten the Sensex so the Rs 66 lakh is a rather conservative figure. In a median fund, the 10 years would have seen your nest egg reach about Rs 1.04 crore. And this, during a decade which has witnessed two huge market crashes!
That’s after absorbing the hit of the worst panic that anyone has ever seen, when the market is at a long-term low point. Once any kind of recovery commences, the value is very likely to shoot up. If this isn’t a perfect demonstration for the value of our slow-and-steady way, then nothing can be.
Over such a long period, the so-called ‘safe’ fixed-income avenues do so much worse than supposedly ‘unsafe’ equity, that the there’s no contest at all. Over this same period, you could have earned an average of no more than around 8 per cent per annum in fixed income investments. The same inputs would leave you with just about Rs 44 lakh, which doesn’t cover even the inflation rate adequately.
The moral of the story: Despite the crashes, equity is the far safer option over the long run. The real danger to your financial well-being is not market crashes, but from the insidious affect of inflation.

Crashes are Your Friends
In the equity markets, you make more money not despite the crashes, but because of the crashes. Let’s modify the above story with the assumption that the post-tech crash of 2000-2001 never happened. The way that crash actually happened, the Sensex reached a peak of about 5,900 in February 2000. It then crashed and went as low as about 2,600 in September 2001. It then started rising and reached the previous peak of ~6,190 again only in January 2004.

Let’s assume that the crash never happened. The Sensex reached 5,600 in March 2000 and then stayed at that level till October 2004. If that had happened, then your Rs 20,000 a month would be worth Rs 55 lakh instead of Rs 66 lakh! That’s right. For the long term investor, the crash of 2000 was worth a lot of money.

How did you make more money because the crash? The answer is obvious to anyone who understands the basic arithmetic of what’s happening here. The crash enabled you to buy cheap and thus eventually raised your total returns. If you are investing steadily for the long-term, then intermittent crashes help you make more money, not less.

And that is how you will eventually profit from the big crashes. Stocks are now cheap, and are probably going to get cheaper. The longer and deeper this crash, the more money you will eventually make. If you know what’s good for you, you should be praying that the Sensex falls to maybe 6000 or 7000 and then stays there for a few months or years before coming to life again.

And that’s the secret of equity investing, the real moral of the story: For the long-term investor, equity is not good despite the occasional crash. It’s good precisely because it crashes. Volatility is your friend. Volatility is what will make you rich.

This story first appeared in the October 2008 issue of Mutual Fund Insight.