Ask Value Research

Are hybrid funds better than debt funds for setting up an SWP?

Dhirendra Kumar lists the suitable options for setting up an SWP

Dhirendra Kumar lists the suitable options for setting up an SWP

Can hybrid funds be a better option than debt funds to set up a Systematic Withdrawal Plan? Which category of hybrid funds should I choose?
- Krishna Kumar Tripathi

Suppose it's a large sum of money and your withdrawal rate is about 4-6 per cent or 7 per cent. You might be better off with a Systematic Withdrawal Plan (SWP) from a hybrid fund because fixed income will get you just as much return as your withdrawal rate. I don't have great expectations from debt mutual funds to give you anything substantially more than inflation. So, if this is your long-term money and your withdrawal expectations are 4 per cent of your capital or more, put your money in a hybrid fund or an all-equity fund depending on your stomach to tolerate volatility. This way, your capital will keep appreciating faster than the withdrawal amount. Maybe a 6-7 per cent withdrawal rate will be possible in a year or two years. Therefore, in my opinion, any conservative investor should consider a hybrid fund for SWP and also choose the right hybrid fund depending on their experience.

It's very important to make the right choice among a conservative hybrid fund or aggressive hybrid fund, or a balanced hybrid fund. Because even a balanced fund or aggressive hybrid fund shows the characters of a pure equity fund in extreme situations. They are not insulated from the equity market volatility risk, but they are more stable than an all-equity fund. If anywhere between 4-5 per cent withdrawal does the needful, choose an aggressive hybrid fund. If you want a little more, go for a balanced fund. If you require even more, like a 6.5-7 per cent, then go for the conservative fund. Because if you continue with your higher withdrawal rate when you are in a more volatile asset allocation, you will eat into your capital at a time when the market has taken a hit. So, higher the withdrawal, get more conservative to ensure that you don't eat into your capital.

Further, one should avoid the exit load while going about SWP. So, the amount required for your next one-year need should be kept in a fixed-income fund and the remaining in a hybrid or equity fund. This way, you start your withdrawals from the latter after one year, so all your investments will become long term and exit load free.

Ask Value Research aks value research information

No question is too small. Share your queries on personal finance, mutual funds, or stocks and let us simplify things for you.


Other Categories

Informed fund ideas, better judgment. Every month. Mutual Fund Insight, every month since October 2002.

Take charge. Know more. Keep more. Mutual Fund Insight helps you do all three — every month