The SEBI's move to approve several recommendations proposed by the mutual fund advisory committee (MFAC) on distributor commissions, total expense ratios (TER), limiting the additional incentive, etc. are expected to have an adverse effect on Asset Management Company (AMC) revenues and profits in future. But that doesn't take away from the fact that FY 2018 was a big year for the AMC industry in India, with assets under management clocking new records. Let us have a look at how AMCs, as businesses, fared. With assets growing at a breakneck speed, the AMC space saw total income of nearly Rs 14000 crore and bottom line surging over Rs 3500 crore.
At an industry level
For AMCs, 2018 was a watershed year. We looked at financial data available for 35 AMCs. So, numbers do not include Essel Mutual Fund, Franklin Templeton Mutual Fund, Invesco Mutual Fund and Mirae Asset Mutual Fund.
Data shows that the 35 AMCs witnessed their collective AUM surge from Rs 16.4 lakh crore to Rs 20 lakh crore in just 12 months. Total income of these AMCs grew to Rs 13944.81 crore in FY18 compared to Rs 10700.34 crore in FY17. As a rate of total income growth, the increase of 30.3% witnessed in FY18 was the highest in six years.
The superb top line growth has had a great effect on the net profit numbers too. For the 35 AMCs, net profit jumped to Rs 3583.47 crore in FY18 from Rs 2610.96 crore in FY17. The 37.2% year on year rise in profit is the biggest surge since FY2014. For those interested in net profit margins, i.e., net profit as a percentage of total income, the number was nearly 26%, which is among the highest since the MF industry came into existence.
|Total income (Rs Cr)||13945||10701||8707||6623||5286|
|Growth YoY (%)||31||23||32||26||21|
|Net profit (Rs Cr)||3584||2611||2088||1541||1333|
|Growth YoY (%)||38||26||36||16||44|
The above numbers do not mean all AMCs clocked profits. As many as 9 AMCs were still in the red in FY18, almost the same number in FY17. We will come to them a little later.
Top 10 revenue earners in FY18
|ICICI Prudential Mutual Fund||1897|
|HDFC Mutual Fund||1867|
|Reliance Mutual Fund||1746|
|SBI Mutual Fund||1272|
|Aditya Birla Sun Life Mutual Fund||1261|
|UTI Mutual Fund||1058|
|Axis Mutual Fund||753|
|DSP Mutual Fund||752|
|Motilal Oswal Mutual Fund||668|
|Kotak Mahindra Mutual Fund||519|
Top 10 profit-makers in FY18
|HDFC Mutual Fund||722|
|ICICI Prudential Mutual Fund||626|
|Reliance Mutual Fund||505|
|UTI Mutual Fund||376|
|SBI Mutual Fund||331|
|Aditya Birla Sun Life Mutual Fund||322|
|DSP Mutual Fund||201|
|Motilal Oswal Mutual Fund||131|
|Kotak Mahindra Mutual Fund||81|
|JM Financial Mutual Fund||57|
A good way of assessing the nature of the AMC business is to see what kind of assets it manages. Since the AMC business is an economy of scale, the biggest AMCs happen to be the most profitable ones, with very few exceptions. Higher persistency and higher expense ratio make equity assets far more important to an AMC. For large AMCs, every Rs 1 crore of equity asset is equivalent to Rs 3 crore of debt asset, or Rs 6-7 crore of liquid fund asset.
The reason behind higher profitability for HDFC AMC, compared to ICICI Prudential, may be due to HDFC's 26.5% equity AUM compared to 23.2% for ICICI Prudential. Even though UTI MF is not in top 5 by total income, its 33% of AUM being in equity may have ensured higher profits than SBI and ABSL.
In terms of fastest profit growth in FY18, smaller AMCs ruled the roost on account of a smaller base effect. LIC Mutual Fund grew its net profit to Rs 6.32 crore from Rs 1.01 crore, clocking 525.68% growth.
AMCs with the highest profit growth
|LIC Mutual Fund||6||1||526|
|Baroda Pioneer Mutual Fund||3||1||196|
|Motilal Oswal Mutual Fund||131||50||164|
|DSP Mutual Fund||201||85||135|
|Kotak Mahindra Mutual Fund||81||38||112|
|IIFL Mutual Fund||30||15||100|
|SBI Mutual Fund||331||224||48|
|Aditya Birla Sun Life Mutual Fund||322||221||46|
|Canara Robeco Mutual Fund||23||16||40|
|HDFC Mutual Fund||722||550||31|
As mentioned earlier, not all AMCs showed profits, despite having sizeable equity assets.
|AMC||2018 (Rs Cr)||2017 (Rs Cr)|
|Mahindra Mutual Fund||-38||-20|
|Edelweiss Mutual Fund||-19||-7|
|Union Mutual Fund||-8||-23|
|Quantum Mutual Fund||-6||0|
|BOI AXA Mutual Fund||-5||-13|
|Sahara Mutual Fund||-4||-4|
|Shriram Mutual Fund||-2||-1|
|Principal Mutual Fund||0||-4|
There is nothing shocking about them because many of them are relatively new businesses.
Though FY18 witnessed net profit climbing to all-time highs, there are AMCs like IDFC, Axis, PPFAS, Indiabulls, BNP Paribas and Taurus whose net profit has fallen year on year. L&T Mutual Fund swung back to black in FY18 with net profit at Rs 31.90 crore compared to net loss of Rs 25.81 in FY17.