For sheer scale and audacity, the Rs 6,000 crore heist that Satyam promoter Ramalinga Raju attempted is breathtaking. Yesterday, the Satyam board of directors approved the acquisition of Maytas Properties and Maytas Infra for USD 1.6 billion. These two companies are promoted by Mr. Raju's son.
It's no secret that no one is willing to invest in real estate companies. Under the circumstances, this deal boils down to Mr. Raju just giving away a gigantic sum of money to his son.
Incidentally, independent directors on the board include Harvard management guru Krishna Palepu, International School of Business (ISB) dean Mendu Rammohan Rao, and former Cabinet Secretary to the Government of India T.R. Prasad. These distinguished luminaries owe some explanations to the non-promoter shareholders whose interests they were supposed to be guarding.
As things stand now, the company has pulled out of the deal. This is not surprising, given the strong reaction from investors. Overnight, the stock's US-listed ADRs lost 55 per cent of their value.
What will Mr. Raju do now? Well, if my understanding of the typical Indian promoter is correct, he will already be hard at work figuring out a smarter way of taking out the money. Let's face it; this type of theft is very much business-as-usual in India. Promoters have myriad ways of enriching themselves at other shareholders' expense. The only mistake the Rajus made was that they tried a method that is more suitable for smaller companies that don't have heavy institutional shareholding and foreign listings. I guess Maytas must be in deep trouble and they must have been desperate.
It is also logical to speculate that there could be some deeper reason for this desperation. Given what has happened to some other promoters recently, it wouldn't come as a surprise to anyone if it turns out that the Rajus' own stake in Satyam is under some sort of a threat.
Incidentally, the promoters' stake in Satyam is merely 8.6 per cent while institutions hold more than 60 percent. It is possible that Mr. Raju will now see institutions forcing changes in the board and possibly in the management. The 8.6 per cent that Mr. Raju controls was worth just Rs 1300 crore, even before the stock price crashed today.
My sense is that we'll be seeing more of such shenanigans now. For about five years, promoters could make enough money by exploiting the rampant capitalisation increase that was happening on the stock markets. Overvalued IPOs was the method of choice till January 2008. Now, that route has been shut off, Mr. Anil Ambani's Reliance Power having been the last successful exploit of that type.
From now on, poor promoters will have to rely on older, more direct methods like Mr. Raju attempted. But make no mistake, he has been thwarted only because his company was too big and the size of the heist was too big. I'm sure such methods must be working well in smaller companies.
Recently Viewed
Notifications
See All- Home
- Stories
- First Page
- The Great Satyam Robbery
The Great Satyam Robbery
Promoter Raju backs out of attempt to give Satyam cash to son
Value Research•December 17, 2008
Top Picks
Welcome to the New Value Research!
2 min read•By Value Research
Hundreds of schemes, a handful of indices
1 min read•By Aakar Rastogi
Value Research Podcast
New episodes every Friday
Who do you complain to?
Every extra layer between you and your investments is a place for responsibility to be avoided
Other Episodes
-
Zero tax for foreigners, a tax on inflation for Indians SEBI wants foreign investors freed from capital gains tax. The Indian saver who stayed while they sold still pays it on gains that are partly just inflation.
-
The cost of growing Growth is only good when it pays its own way
-
Cap the Investor, Not the Industry A per-person limit on the fund route would steady the rupee better than freezing the whole industry
-
Your fund lost money. That doesn't make it a bad fund. September and October have left most portfolios in the red. That number says more about when you invested than about the fund you chose.
Other Categories
Redirecting you to MF Central in
You'll be redirected to MF Central shortly. Complete the process there, then return to Value Research to upload the QR code and finish importing your portfolio.
Still Confused? Read The Quick User Guide
Upload the QR Code
Please upload the QR code downloaded from the MF Central platform in the field provided below
Seems like you've uploaded a wrong QR code. Please upload the QR code downloaded from MF Central platform.
Need to Re-Initiate? Go back to MF Central Platform
CAS Request Flow
Troubleshoot Guide
Complete the 5-step journey
-
1
Initiate the import on Value Research
Enter your email ID or mobile number linked to your mutual fund investments. Click on the "Use 1 Import" button.
You will be redirected to the MFC (MF Central) platform to continue the process. - 2 Authenticate on MF Central After being redirected to the MFC platform, enter the OTP received from MFC. Click on the “Authenticate with OTP” button to proceed.
-
3
Select the Correct CAS Configuration
On the CAS configuration screen, ensure the following options are selected:
- Under “What type of data can be shared?”, select “Both Regular + Direct Investments” (this is selected by default).
- Under “What extent of data can be shared?”, select “Transactions” (this is selected by default).
- Under “Select the AMCs you want to include?”, select “Select All the AMCs”.
-
4
Download the QR Code and Return to Value Research
Once the QR code is generated, click on the “Download QR Code” button to download it.
On the final screen, click on the “Continue” button. You will then be redirected back to the Value Research platform. -
5
Upload the QR Code to Complete the Import
Upload the downloaded QR code on the Value Research platform.
After a successful upload, the import process will begin automatically. The process usually takes 1–2 minutes. Once completed, your mutual fund investments will be imported successfully.
- 1 Are you only seeing Regular or Direct Mutual funds in your portfolio? Please ensure that you have selected both “Regular and Direct” investment options. Selecting only one option will result in the import of that specific investment type only.
- 2 Are you only seeing a limited number of funds in your portfolio? Please select the “ALL AMC” option to ensure that funds from all AMCs are included and displayed in the portfolio.
Informed fund ideas, better judgment. Every month. Mutual Fund Insight, every month since October 2002.
Take charge. Know more. Keep more. Mutual Fund Insight helps you do all three — every month
Notifications
Unlock Custom duration
Please subscribe to Value Research Fund Advisor to unlock the custom duration feature and enhance your experience.
Recommendations for the best investments and allocations that are most optimal for your goal
Backed by research by a team of investment experts with over 30 years of experience
Continuous analysis and support from our team to make sure your goals stay on track
Share on Social media